5 Ways to Show vs Tell in Fiction Writing - #WriteTip #AmWriting

May 10, 2015



This guest post is from the amazing online editing software AutoCrit. As most of you know, I’ve been a strong promoter of AutoCrit for years. One of the things that I’m always mentioning to my clients and critique partners is the Deep POV method, or more commonly referred to as “show vs. tell” in fiction. Now there are many different ways to achieve Deeper POV, but here are a few great examples to help you understand why this technique is so awesome!
Show, don’t tell.
It’s the first rule of writing, and for good reason.
In a nutshell, showing is about using description and action to help the reader experience the story. Telling is when the author summarizes or uses exposition to simply tell the reader what is happening.
For example:
Telling: John was sad to see his girlfriend leave.
Showing: John wiped tears down his face as he watched his girlfriend board the plane.
Here’s a longer example:
Telling: The house was creepy.
Showing: Only a single dim candle lit the room. The house smelled like dust and rotting wood, and something faintly metallic that made John think of blood. Stuffed animals were mounted around the room: a wild-eyed buck, a grizzly frozen in fury, a screech owl with sharp yellow talons.

***

In both examples, showing makes the writing vivid and more descriptive. Showing also helps readers experience the story by allowing them to interpret the descriptions of places, actions, and scenes.
Telling, on the other hand, is flat and boring and limits the experience for the reader. It also tells editors and agents you’re an amateur. After all, if the very first rule of writing is show, don’t tell, then telling says you don’t know the first thing about writing.
So how do you turn a tell into a show?  

Here are four great strategies:

  • Use strong verbs: Don’t use walk if you can say gallop, skip, saunter, stroll or amble.
  • Use specific nouns and clear adjectives in descriptions that paint a picture for the reader. Don't just tell us Grandma baked a pie; say a cinnamon-apple pie with a golden crust rested on the windowsill above the sink.
  • Include sensory details—describe how something sees, smells, sounds, tastes, and feels
  • Use dialogue: ‘“Don’t you walk out of here!” Mom yelled’ is better than Mom was angry.

The exception to the rule:
Contrary to popular belief, there are times when telling may be better than showing—namely, when describing how a character thinks or feels about a certain situation, otherwise known as internal narrative or introspection.
Internal narrative is the private monologue that makes readers feel as though we’re inside a character’s head, privy to thoughts and feelings the character doesn't necessarily express out loud or through his actions.  Internal narrative is essential because it helps us understand exactly what makes a character tick—his fears, his motivations, his secret dreams. Getting to walk around in a character’s head for a while is one of the best parts about reading, and you’re depriving your reader of that pleasure if you don’t have clear, detailed internal narrative. However, it is usually better to show this through dialogue, actions, and reactions within the narrative.
Telling is sometimes a better strategy than showing when it comes to writing internal narrative.
Here’s why: Showing relies on a character’s actions.
“He shoved back his chair and slammed his fist against the table.”
This might show us that a character is angry, but we have no idea what he’s actually thinking. Maybe he’s not really angry, but scared. Or maybe he’s secretly thrilled but is pretending to be outraged. We don’t know unless you tell us.
Yes, in nine cases out of ten, it’s infinitely preferable to show John is angry by describing the way his fist hit the table or how hard he slammed the door on his way out of the room. But sometimes, you just need to tell it like it is.
Related areas to look for in your manuscript:
If AutoCrit finds that you tend to tell instead of show, you may be guilty of several similar writer gaffes, such as using too many adverbs, relying on generic descriptions, or writing weak dialogue. All three of these writing styles are forms of telling that will put your reader to sleep. But never fear: AutoCrit can help you spot those pitfalls too, so you can keep your prose—and your reader—energized.
The bottom line
Showing versus telling is the essence of good storytelling.  In 99 percent of cases, it’s better to show.

***

Most editors and successful authors will agree that the most common shallow words found in narrative that take you out of Deep POV (show instead of tell) are: felt, see/saw, heard/hear, smell/smelled, knew/know, realize/realized, notice/noticed, wonder/wondered.
(Of course, these words are perfectly okay to use in dialogue and should not be revised.)
The best way to convey your character’s thoughts, senses, emotions, and feelings is to show them though powerful description. To do this, try depicting the character’s physical reactions along with the emotional ones.
Remember to always use the concept of the show and don’t tell in your fiction writing. This tenet means describing what a character is feeling without actually “stating the emotion” for the reader.
Showing takes a lot more creativity than “telling,” but trust me, it will pay off by giving your readers a much more powerful and believable story.
Eliminate "naming the emotion" and show the feeling instead.
SHALLOW: Nikki groaned in frustration. (Cliché)

DEEP POV: Groaning, Nikki dropped her head in her hands.

***

Being able to describe those emotions through Deep POV adds mastery to your writing. Add your character’s five senses to describe how he/she is feeling without naming the emotion, and watch your scenes come vividly to life. 

 


For more insight in writing Deep POV, please check out, "Writers Guide to Character Emotion" at these online retailers.


The Best Method to Creating Realistic Character Expression and Emotion

*AMAZON BESTSELLER in EDITING, WRITING & REFERENCE*

Most writers struggle with creating a captivating story. The fastest way to improve your writing is by the use of the “Deep Point-of-View” technique, which can transform any novel from mediocre storytelling into riveting prose. This handbook is great for self-published authors, short story writers, and even published authors wanting to instantly enhance their writing skills.

This manual will also explain how you can greatly enhance your characterization by eliminating filtering words, and includes hundreds of amazing tips on how to submerge your readers so deeply into any scene that they will experience the story along with your characters. Also, learn how to avoid “telling” by applying “showing” methods through powerful examples that will deepen the reader’s experience through vivid, sensory details.

Are you ready to instantly take your writing skills to the next level?
BUY A COPY TODAY!

5 comments :

  1. Thank you :) I'm using this posting as a check list for a book wide revision, as I tend to fall back into bad habits sometimes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I hope it helps! If you have any questions, please let me know. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Will do, and thank you. :)

    I looked for a facbook like button but can't find one, consider adding one when you can?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for the reminder! When I updated my new blog template, it removed my FB link. Added it now...

    ReplyDelete
  5. You're welcome, great. :)

    ReplyDelete

I absolutely love hearing from my followers! Thank you so, so much for your comments. Consider yourself awesome!

(Please do not spam me. I moderate all comments, so do not waste your time.)

Free Blogger Design Made By The Dutch Lady Designs